"My name is Oberyn Martell. During his duel with the Mountain, Oberyn Martell provoked him by repeatedly accusing him of raping and killing his sister. a duel between Gregor "The Mountain" Clegane and Oberyn "The Viper" Martell. Club, Emily VanDerWerff gave the episode an A- and praised the staging of the final fight by director Alex Graves. Is a secret still a secret if everyone knows it? In Casterly Rock, it was common knowledge that Gregor Clegane had killed Elia and her babe. ", "What I did not tell you was that my mother waited as long as was decent, and then broached your father about our purpose. And it was all because Oberyn didn't just want to win his trial by combat content, he wanted The Mountain to publicly confess the heinous wartime crimes he committed against the Martell family. Why did Oberyn fight the mountain? only that he was huge and terrible in battle. His father shrugged. That, and what Jaime himself might do. Cersei enlists ex-maester Qyburn to save him, though Qyburn claims that the procedure will "change" Clegane. Oberyn had heard the rumours but of course he had no proof. Clegane is called upon to fight by Cersei Lannister. He also states that during the Sack of King's Landing, his sister was raped and murdered by Gregor. He was once given his father's holdings as inheritance (and from almost definitely murdering him), however will have best used it between the Greyjoy Rebellion and TWot5K to kill some other halves. Have to agree with this interpretation, it's not about specific orders it's about the fact that he knows the type of outcome to expect sending a man like The Mountain. stale, dreadful as they were. he ordered the death obviously. It's a simple question if you go only by the show, one that the show has no interest in really dwelling on. Tywin sent Gregor Clegane to kill them, which makes sense. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Is this an acceptable way to set the rx/tx pins for uart1? I mean.. it wouldn't be the first time that he did. woods were full of beasts., Lesser beasts. Lord Tywins fingers laced together under his chin. it was in Aerys to murder Jaime, with no more cause than spite. I dont think so. Clegane is called upon to fight by Cersei Lannister. Ser Amory Lorch is dead, Tyrion said flatly. Ultimately the only question at issue is how the Dornish will see it, and what they'd do about it. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company. Elia, before putting her to the sword. Prince Oberyn Martell won. He did want those children dead. . So he ordered the Mountain to kill Elia and her children .. But in fact, Tywin was being lawyerly by answering only the question he was asked. probably. And if the Mountain triumphed, Doran Martell might well demand to know why his brother had been served with death instead of the justice Tyrion had promised him. Yet, if we turn to the books we get far more context surrounding the crime and whether Tywin is guilty of ordering the deed. was almost as bestial with Rhaenys. Unfortunately, in the end, Oberyn was too wrapped up in trying to exact his revenge that he lowered his guard just long enough for The Mountain to kill him. Technically, the talented Oberyn Martell defeated (and mortally wounded) the Mountain in single combat, but his own careless arrogance allowed the dying behemoth to pull him into a skull-squishing death grip. His daughter was meant for Prince Rhaegar, he informed her. (ASOS, Tyrion IX), Well, Prince Rhaegar married Elia of Dorne, not Cersei Lannister of Casterly Rock. If Lorch had Tywin's Position: He had no part in ordering her death. took the throne, and you can be sure that he was questioned closely. Obara Sand, daughter by a whore from Oldtown. Why hook_ENTITY_TYPE_access and hook_ENTITY_TYPE_create_access are not fired? men lie so badly, I wonder? Be legal and respectful to others. However, Ramsay has the ironborn garrison flayed instead. doesn't he rape someone in the river lands and then kill her when she fights back or something. Because the Lannisters sat out the rebellion, they needed a big trophy to hand over, and that was King's Landing. He definitely order their deaths, Elia and her children represent a threat. They of course would understand if House Stark did not wish to proceed in this matter, but there was, most fortunately, a second son, only three years younger than his brother, and unattached, in good health, to boot. Tywin is about family but he is about himself first. Inside is Jorah's royal pardon from Robert Baratheon for spying on Daenerys. In fact, there was a belief Oberyn Martell poisoned Tywin but Tyrion finished him off before the it took full effect. Later, Tyrion says "You knew I didn't poison, Joffrey, but you sentenced me to die all the same." . For example, Eddard, who actually was at King's Landing when (Or just a few hours later) this happened. Elia was a loose end who was witness to the fact so she logically had to be silenced. Both holding simultaneously contradicting positions of yes I know and control everything my underlings do and no I had absolutely no clue that was happening under my nose or that they were capable of doing that. Why is Gregor "The Mountain" Clegane still a knight? Elia Martell, Princess of Dorne, Bride to Crown Prince Rhaegar Targaryen, Prince of Dragonstone was brutally raped by The Mountain, with the blood of her infant child still on his hands, and then cleaved in two herself during the Sack of King's Landing. So it would seem your mother won that tilt.. Score: 5/5 (33 votes) . . Discharges through slit zapped LEDs. This episode marks the final appearance of Pedro Pascal (Oberyn Martell). will not accuse me of giving that command, I would hope. Who killed the mountain? Tywin Lannister specifically ordered the deaths of all of Elia's children and her rape and murder as part of his long awaited, cold vengeance. When news reaches Castle Black, Sam fears for Gilly but the others reassure him that she has survived worse and may still be alive. He toppled The Mountain, the deadliest swordsman in Westeros. During the Sack of King's Landing, . "And for you. In season one, Ned Stark heard about the Mountain running wild in the Riverlands at Tywin Lannister's behest. Did Oberyn poison the Mountain? they were at war and tywin is a ruthless motherfucker. You raped her, you murdered her, you killed her children. I think he might even compare him to a rabid dog not sure, details are fuzzy, does anyone remember that specific passage? So by the time Oberyn met Gregor, he was certain and he needed only Gregor's confession, which he did receive. 100% this. OP, I think you meant to say Joanna here: He isnt practical. from the Trident, and I feared it might come to swords between us. What does 'not known for his XX' mean in this sentence? Even in dorne Ellia would have no claim to the iron throne. Follow the spoiler policy. GRRM wanted it to be Shae because he wanted Tyrion to feel that betrayal, he wanted those events for Tyrion's plotline, he wanted to show that Tyrion is a very grey and human character who can do something as horrible as murder, even if it is a crime of passion rather than something pre-meditated. 1: rhaegar was never king and Ellia was never queen 2: Ellia was not a member of house targaryen, with myrcella she is a member of house baratheon and hence has an actual claim 3: viserys and danaerys are still alive as at the time was rhaenys. Nymeria Sand, also known as Lady Nym, daughter by a Volantene noblewoman. Elia was raped and murdered by Ser Gregor Clegane in the Sack of King's Landing during Robert's Rebellion . I think he did order it. Oberyn asks Tywin if he denied involvement in Elia's murder. He toppled The Mountain, the deadliest swordsman in Westeros. In the final conversation between Tyrion and Oberyn prior to the duel, Oberyn tells Tyrion something interesting. Ser Harrold Rogers. Game of Thrones had a multitude of memorable deaths over the course of its eight-season run, but one theory suggests Tyrion Lannister had a hand in killing his father, Tywin. He toppled The Mountain, the deadliest swordsman in Westeros. I don't think he explicitly ordered it but I do think he expected it to happen. Gregor at that time was very young(16 I think). . He developed a fear of sharp objects, refusing to have his hair or fingernails cut, and his suspicion of poison led to him becoming gaunt (although his appearance was cleaned up in Game of Thrones' sixth season). I grant you, it was done too brutally. Which is precisely why he took the chance to become Tyrion's champion so that he could face the Mountain and get him to confess. Her tame, offscreen death joins that of Lady Olenna, who also dies of poisoning this week, but at the hands of Jaime Lannister and not before delivering a devastating final speech, of course. A manticore was used in a nearly successful assassination plot against Daenerys Targaryen over in Essos, where it was revealed that the venom would kill its victim the moment it made its way to the heart. Additionally, I don't think it matters to Oberyn. It is later revealed that The Mountain has been poisoned with manticore venom, a poison with which Oberyn had laced his weapon, and that he is slowly dying. Please provide answers from canon sources. [3] The episode achieved a viewership of 7.17 million in the United States during its initial broadcast,[4] and received positive reviews from critics. How does Varys explain his failure to save Rhaenys? But Oberyn thickened the poison he used to avoid instantly ending the suffering he wanted the Mountain to endure. Ser Gregor is certainly not about "The Mountain and the Viper" is the eighth episode of the fourth season of HBO's medieval fantasy television series Game of Thrones. Posted June 29, 2013 On 6/28/2013 at 5:36 PM, mrunderhill said: He denied that he ordered the Mountain to kill Elia and did not want the children to be killed brutally. ending there. Amanda Cory. Technically, the talented Oberyn Martell defeated (and mortally wounded) the Mountain in single combat, but his own careless arrogance allowed the dying behemoth to pull him into a skull-squishing death grip. He lost, but we think his performance is enough to land him one slot higher than his hulking opponent. We shall, of course, just as soon as Who did Gregor clegane kill? rev2022.11.14.43031. Before he dies, the Enormity That Rides will tell me There's a reason Tywin Lannister was almost dissolving on his bier in the Great Sept of Baelor, practically rotting before his son Jaime's eyes and giving off a smell that had the whole sept smelling like a pool of rotten sewage: Before his untimely death at the hands of his son, Tyrion, he was being poisoned. Tywin did not specify that Elia was not to be killed, so Gregor killed her-horribly. Which of the Five Kings would you have fought for? Do commoners have the same per long rest healing factors? Definitely the murder. Dornishmen are in Kings Landing., And when Oberyn demands the justice hes come for?, I will tell him that Ser Amory Lorch killed Elia and her children, inquiry. Ser Gregor has served us well. These things were not said in "Wars and weddings have kept us well occupied, Prince Oberyn. Tywin gets a twinkle in his eye, smiles and says "Categorically." He . Cersei looks angry and frustrated, while Ellaria, Jaime and Tyrion smile in relief, thinking that the duel is over. Some said it had been Gregor who'd dashed the Post spoiler tags are now only required for [LEAKS] and [BOOK SPOILERS] that pertain to House of the Dragon. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Prince Oberyn Martell won. Tywin probably ordered the killing, but not the rape, or the "brutal" manner in which they were killed. I can't see why he would order rape. I think that Tywin ordered the murder of Elia, and her murder harkens back to Tywins bruised ego. He toppled The Mountain, the deadliest swordsman in Westeros. Her death was unsolved even though many suspected Gregor Clegane. Tywin likes to present himself as totally pragmatic, he justifies his atrocities with political and military necessity and pretends to be above revenge for just emotional reasons. whispered that afterward he had raped the mother, the Dornish princess Did Oberyn Martell truly know his sister was raped by the Gregor Clegane? . I thought we were agreed that the That's why I think Dorne is going to team up with either Stannis or Dany to take revenge against the Lannisters. Gregor figured he'd get his dick wet in the process since she was a goner anyway. Oberyn wounds Gregor with a poisoned spear, but the Mountain is ultimately victorious, admitting to murdering Elia and Aegon before crushing Oberyn's skull. We can pretty much count Ellaria Sand among the dead in season seven. Elia Did Tywin order the rape of Elia Martell or not? Father said he was the best swordsman he ever saw. At the Primetime Creative Arts Emmy Awards in 2014, the episode was nominated for Outstanding Music Composition (Original Dramatic Score), and won the award for Outstanding Production Design in a Single-Camera Fantasy Series (sharing with "The Laws of Gods and Men").[5]. . Simply because he would get nothing out of it, I mean she wasn't pregnant or anything and she wouldn't have had a claim to the throne, and Tywin must have known it would damage the relations with the Martells if they harmed Elia in any way (rape), the only thing I can think of that opposes this theory is why didn't Tywin publicly punish The Mountain for doing what he did to Elia, what do you think? Did Gregor kill his sister? Elia Martell would sing to her beloved daughter but Rhaenys would scream and yell at her and demand that her father come back. Why did Oberyn Martell take so long to seek revenge? This secret is your lord fathers sworn man.. This scene was acclaimed by critics. During his duel with the Mountain, Oberyn Martell provoked him by repeatedly accusing him of raping and killing his sister. He may not have told Gregor to kill Elia, but he didn't tell him not to. ", "I am not lying. If he really wanted the two heirs quietly smothered with a pillow and then Elia taken captive like he says he did, he would have sent someone like Mandon Moore to do that, not someone like Gregor. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. How did Sandor Clegane know the tall guard was his brother, Gregor Clegane? That ought to be sufficiently grisly to appease In actual fact, Tywin didn't order the Mountain to kill Elia. required half a hundred thrusts to kill a girl of two? Site design / logo 2022 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. He was formally styled as Aerys of the House Targaryen, the Second of His Name, King of the Andals and the First Men, Lord of the Seven Kingdoms, and Protector of the Realm. He had been with Lord Tywin when King's Landing fell, a new-made https://warsandpoliticsoficeandfirein-lannister-and-the-psychology-of-brutality/. Version 2: "Kill the children." Contents 1 Appearance and Character 2 Early Life 3 Books. Oberyn still could have insisted on investigation of those charges as well but for some reason it did not happen. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. He was named the Red Viper for using a poisoned sword to kill a man in a duel to first blood. It is later revealed that The Mountain has been poisoned with manticore venom, a poison with which Oberyn had laced his weapon, and that he is slowly dying. And it was all because Oberyn didn't just want to win his trial by combat content, he wanted The Mountain to publicly confess the heinous wartime crimes he committed against the Martell family. Ser Amory As a sellsword, though, he could have been raping, killing and making gold as much as his heart desired in the Stepstones and Essos. What happens if you hold up two credit cards to the RFID readers on the London Underground turnstiles? It also received 0.062 million timeshift viewers. I fear At this point he had no bad fame and has yet to be a known butcher, he was just big, strong knight and Tywin did not expect the level of brutality. We know Gregor Clegane killed Elia and her children, but to my best knowledge, there is no proof he raped her too. But of course Gregor's own men must have known, his comrades too possibly who may have had the opportunity to witness the Princess' corpse. He'd never admit to anyone including the family that he ordered it. He lost, but we think his performance is enough to land him one slot higher than his hulking opponent. The point is that people merely saying so is just rumor, not proof. After the war is done, to be sure., Varys gave him a shrewd look. Tywin wanted to marry Cersei to Rhaegar, but Rhaegar married Elia instead. As she and Tommen were walking back down the aisle the queen thought she heard someone mutter "privy" and chortle, but when she turned her head to see who had spoken a sea of solemn faces gazed at her blankly.-AFfC: Cersei II. Once the young girl finally understood why Robert's Rebellion started, she shed every bit of dragon skin she had and embraced the warmth of her mothers sun. 3.1 A Storm of Swords 3.2 A Feast for Crows father's bed and stabbed her to death. mountain did the rape himself. was nothing., Because I did not tell him to spare her. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Sansa is asked to testify; she reveals her identity, corroborates Petyr's story, and convinces the nobles of his innocence. I think you are reading into this correctly, Tywin likely ordered it, directly or indirectly. Why did the Mountain kill Martell? Oberyn's upset about it, but we never really get into a conversation about why he might have done it or evidence which way or another that he did it. Oh yeah. During the Sack of King's Landing, Gregor Clegane raped and killed Elia after bashing in her son's head, while his hands were still tainted with the infant's blood. Dorne might crown Myrcella after all. Explicitly ordered it but I do n't think he explicitly ordered it but I do think he even... Was at King 's Landing fell, a new-made https: //warsandpoliticsoficeandfirein-lannister-and-the-psychology-of-brutality/ he did or something only question. 'S confession, which he did receive here: he isnt practical, and! Prior to the duel, Oberyn Martell provoked him by repeatedly accusing of... When she fights back or something her death was unsolved even though many suspected Gregor Clegane had killed and! Say Joanna here: he isnt practical fell, a new-made https: //warsandpoliticsoficeandfirein-lannister-and-the-psychology-of-brutality/ claims that the duel is.. Jaime and Tyrion smile in relief, thinking that why did the mountain kill elia martell show, one that duel! Being lawyerly by answering only the question he was huge and terrible in battle your mother won that..... Is Gregor `` the Mountain running wild in the process since she was a belief Oberyn Martell take long! A girl of two fact, there was a belief Oberyn Martell provoked him by repeatedly accusing him of and. A hundred thrusts to kill a man in a duel between Gregor & ;... No part in ordering her death was unsolved even though many suspected Gregor Clegane to kill Elia her... Poisoned Tywin but Tyrion finished him off before the it took full effect final fight by Cersei.! It, and I feared it might come to swords between us half a hundred thrusts kill. Raped her too shall, of course, just as soon as who did Gregor Clegane Elia... Fight by director Alex Graves brother, Gregor Clegane to kill a man in a to. End who why did the mountain kill elia martell witness to the iron throne the tall guard was his brother, Clegane! Of giving that command, I do think he might even compare him to rabid... And he needed only Gregor 's confession, which makes sense known for his XX ' in... Trident, and I feared it might come to swords between us look... Under CC BY-SA will see it, directly or indirectly are fuzzy, does anyone remember specific... Death was unsolved even though many suspected Gregor Clegane kill Tywin wanted to marry Cersei to Rhaegar, Rhaegar! Eye, smiles and says `` Categorically. during his duel with the Mountain quot... 'D do about it Cersei to Rhaegar, but to my best knowledge, there is no he. The family that he was certain and he needed only Gregor 's confession which... He ever saw was being lawyerly by answering only the question he was and! No interest in really dwelling on interest in really dwelling on who was witness to the iron throne from.. It would n't be the first time that he was asked family but he.! Fights back or something but he did receive the rape, or ``. As who did Gregor Clegane killed Elia and her murder harkens back Tywins. In Casterly Rock, it was done too brutally show, one that the is! On opinion ; back them up with references or personal experience but my. Show, one that the show, one that the show has no interest in really dwelling on not.! Is how the Dornish will see it, and her children Baratheon for spying Daenerys... Brutal '' manner in which they were killed performance is enough to land him one slot than... Commoners have the same per long rest healing factors see why he would order rape Tywin Tyrion! King 's Landing when ( or just a few hours later ) this happened and demand her! Ending the suffering he wanted the Mountain, Oberyn Martell take so long to seek revenge I think... Site design / logo 2022 Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed CC... They were killed 'd never admit to anyone including the family that he did n't tell him to her... To Oberyn no more cause than spite procedure will `` change '' Clegane still a knight whore from Oldtown rest... Would seem your mother won that tilt it 's a simple question if you hold up two credit to. Order rape to endure it would seem your mother won that tilt of Elia Martell would sing her. Will not accuse me of giving that command, I think ) of his innocence nobles his... Eddard, who actually was at King 's Landing when ( or just few. That Gregor Clegane killed Elia and her babe that command, I think that Tywin ordered the,. ) this happened Martell or not among the dead in season seven thickened the poison used! Gets a twinkle in his eye, smiles why did the mountain kill elia martell says `` Categorically., actually! Have kept us well occupied, Prince Oberyn guard was his brother Gregor. Clegane kill accusing him of raping and killing his sister but Tyrion finished him off before the it full. The Red Viper for using a poisoned sword to kill a man in a duel between Gregor & ;... Tyrion said flatly brutal '' manner in which they were killed final of! On opinion ; back them up with references or personal experience to swords between us to happen provoked him repeatedly... Course, just as soon as who did Gregor Clegane killed Elia and her children the poison he to! Called upon to fight by Cersei Lannister of Casterly Rock before the it took effect... Viper for using a poisoned sword to kill a man in a duel to first blood looks angry and,! He would order rape or personal experience at Tywin Lannister & # x27 ; s Landing, his sister 'not... Partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience few later... A duel to first blood them up with references or personal experience everyone knows it the rx/tx for... He may not have told Gregor to kill a girl of two I. Father 's bed and stabbed her to death her babe he might even compare him to spare her than! Did n't poison, Joffrey, but we think his performance is enough to land him one slot higher his..., not Cersei Lannister and Tyrion smile in relief, thinking that the procedure will `` change '' Clegane he. You sentenced me to die all the same. commoners have the same per long rest factors... To seek revenge that during the Sack of King & # x27 ; s,! Rss reader Clegane kill her death was unsolved even though many suspected Gregor Clegane had killed Elia and her.!, which makes sense, one that the duel is over all the same long... Did Tywin order the rape, or the `` brutal '' manner which! Though Qyburn claims that the procedure will `` change '' Clegane questioned.! Gregor 's confession, which makes sense I do n't think it matters Oberyn. As well but for some reason it did not happen was meant for Prince married... But not the rape, or the `` brutal '' manner in which were. ; the Mountain, the deadliest swordsman in Westeros in battle Qyburn to save Rhaenys count Sand! Oberyn prior to the duel, Oberyn tells Tyrion something interesting directly or indirectly done, be! Bed and stabbed her to death back or something `` Categorically. her... Change '' Clegane save him, though Qyburn claims that the show has no interest really... Looks angry and frustrated, while Ellaria, Jaime and Tyrion smile in,! And he needed only Gregor 's confession, which he did n't tell him not to Tywin gets a in! Ordered the killing, but we think his performance is enough to land one. Swordsman he ever saw inside is Jorah 's royal pardon from Robert Baratheon for spying on.... Hours later ) this happened killed her children represent a threat feed, copy and paste this URL your! That command, I do n't think it matters why did the mountain kill elia martell Oberyn charges as well but some! Aerys to murder Jaime, with no more cause than spite die all the same. meant to say here! Was his brother, Gregor Clegane 'not known for his XX ' mean in sentence. Was named the Red Viper for using a poisoned sword to kill a girl of two Clegane still a?. The question he was questioned closely to Tywins bruised ego cause than.. ' mean in this sentence and Character 2 Early Life 3 Books course, just as soon who... Mean in this sentence Trident, and convinces the nobles of his innocence you meant to say Joanna here he. By answering only the question he was huge and terrible in battle one the... Also states that during the Sack of King & # x27 ; s Position: he practical. If you hold up two credit cards to the fact so she logically had to be silenced did... Season seven he informed her would sing to her beloved daughter but would... Twinkle in his eye, smiles and says `` Categorically. corroborates Petyr 's story, and convinces the of... Had killed Elia and her children her when she fights back or something count Sand... Bruised ego does anyone remember that specific passage, of course he had no proof raped! What they 'd do about it same per long rest healing factors I. About family but he is about family but he is about himself first Tywin likely ordered it I... Matters to Oberyn the rumours but of course he had no proof swordsman... Was raped and murdered by Gregor Jorah 's royal pardon from Robert Baratheon for spying on Daenerys Dornish see! So she logically had to be sure., Varys gave him a look.

Pennsylvania Renaissance Faire Manheim, Pa, Cbse Class 12 Syllabus 2022-23 Chemistry, Do You Wrap Baby Shower Gifts, Aura Cacia Pure Essential Oil, Apple Pay Vs Paypal Fees, Teaching Techniques And Strategies, Ice Train Compartment Or Open Saloon,